Skip to content
1 / 104
For saleMLS® X13118556

217 Butler Street, Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON L0S 1J0

Town · L0S 1J0

$4,750,000

$950 / sq ft

5 months on market

Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
6
Interior
5,000 sf
Parking
5
Lot
138 × 200 ft

What's special

  • Built-in garage
  • Pool
  • Central air
  • Finished basement
  • 6 fireplaces
  • Central vacuum
  • Guest accommodations
  • In-law suite

Book a private showing

Pick a time that suits you. No obligation.

Loading open times…

About this property

Situated in one of Niagara-on-the-Lake's most admired settings, this remarkable property offers a rare combination of scale, character, privacy, and location. Set on nearly an acre at the prominent corner of Queen and Butler, the home captures beautiful outlooks across the golf course (the oldest golf course in Ontario, and one of the oldest in Canada) toward Lake Ontario, all within steps of the shops, restaurants, and charm of Queen Street. The classic white clapboard residence offers more than 5,500 square feet above grade and has been thoughtfully restored, renovated, and expanded to create a warm and inviting home with generous principal spaces. Gas and wood-burning fireplaces add character throughout, while multiple walkouts create an effortless connection to the gardens and outdoor living areas. The property also includes a separate annex, offering excellent flexibility for guests, family, or private work space, with a bedroom, living and dining area, kitchen, and den or second bedroom. The annex was originally converted from a two-car garage, and it could be converted back. Outdoors, the grounds feel like a private retreat. Mature trees, English-style gardens, flagstone patios, a koi pond with bubbler fountain, and a large inground pool create a series of beautiful spaces for relaxing, entertaining, and enjoying the sun throughout the day. A special offering in one of Niagara's most desirable locations, this property would be equally well suited as an elegant year-round residence or as a memorable getaway for gathering with family and friends. Enjoy all that the Niagara Region has to offer; the Shaw Festival, golf, biking, boating, wineries, and more!

Rooms

12 rooms. Dimensions as published by the listing brokerage.

Room dimensions and features
RoomLevelDimensionsFeatures
Living RoomMain7.44 × 5.95 m24.4 × 19.5 ftWet Bar · Gas Fireplace · Bay Window
SunroomMain9.00 × 5.94 m29.5 × 19.5 ftCathedral Ceiling(s) · Gas Fireplace · Sliding Doors
SittingMain5.17 × 5.07 m17.0 × 16.6 ftCoffered Ceiling(s) · French Doors · Gas Fireplace
LibraryMain6.97 × 4.80 m22.9 × 15.7 ftCrown Moulding · Fireplace · B/I Bookcase
Dining RoomMain6.01 × 4.57 m19.7 × 15.0 ftHardwood Floor · Fireplace · French Doors
KitchenMain5.74 × 4.79 m18.8 × 15.7 ftCentre Island · Breakfast Bar · W/O To Garden
BreakfastMain4.96 × 3.87 m16.3 × 12.7 ftWet Bar · Bay Window · Hardwood Floor
Primary BedroomSecond4.06 × 3.79 m13.3 × 12.4 ftDouble Closet · Juliette Balcony · Gas Fireplace
SittingSecond4.86 × 3.79 m15.9 × 12.4 ftHardwood Floor · Overlooks Pool · Window Floor to Ceiling
Bedroom 2Second4.64 × 3.09 m15.2 × 10.1 ftHardwood Floor · Double Closet · Semi Ensuite
Bedroom 3Second4.91 × 3.48 m16.1 × 11.4 ftHardwood Floor · Closet · Overlooks Garden
Bedroom 4Second6.22 × 5.27 m20.4 × 17.3 ftHardwood Floor · Closet · 4 Pc Ensuite

Features

  • Central Vacuum
  • Guest Accommodations
  • In-Law Suite
  • Water Heater

Property details

Property

Property type
detached
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
6
Interior size
5,000 sq ft
Lot size
138 × 200 ft
Zoning
Residential
Possession
90 Days / TBA

Interior

Basement
Unfinished
Heating
Forced Air · Gas
Cooling
Central Air
Fireplaces
6
Exposure
West

Exterior & services

Construction
Wood
Garage
Built-In
Parking spaces
5
Pool
Inground
Sewer
Sewer

Costs

List price
$4,750,000
Property taxes
$28,668 / year (2025)
Price per sq ft
$950

Listing

MLS® number
X13118556
Status
For sale
Listed
May 12, 2026
Days on market
177
Last updated
October 26, 2026
Listing brokerage
Johnston & Daniel

Price & sale history

This property's sale history is hidden

TRREB rules require a free account before sold and leased prices can be shown. One registration unlocks full sale history across the site.

Unlock sale history & sold price

Free. Takes about twenty seconds.

Before you make an offer

What this home costs beyond the asking price, and how that price compares to what else is on the market.

How this price compares

This home is priced above most comparable listings — about 95% of comparable detached listings in Town are asking less.

$854KMedian $1.42M$3.70M
This home
$950 / sq ft
Comparable median
$847 / sq ft

Based on 56 comparable active detached listings in Town. These are asking prices, not sale prices.

Mortgage estimate

Down payment20.0% · minimum $950,000
$950,000
Interest rate5-year fixed, illustrative only
4.49%
Amortization
Principal & interest
$21,010.85
Property tax (est.)
$2,389.01
Estimated monthly
$23,400

Estimate only. Excludes CMHC insurance premiums, which apply below 20% down, and does not constitute a mortgage approval or an offer of credit.

Land transfer tax

Payable on closing, on top of the purchase price.

Ontario
$105,225
Total due on closing
$105,225

An estimate on the asking price of $4,750,000. Rates current as of September 2026; confirm the final figure with your real estate lawyer.

Listing courtesy of Johnston & Daniel. Listing data is provided in part by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. Information is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties. Data is updated every 15 minutes.

$4,750,000

Contact Book a viewing

Comparable sales nearby

What similar homes in this area actually sold for.

Nearby sold prices are hidden

Recent closed sales for comparable homes in this area — the numbers that tell you whether the asking price is realistic.

Unlock nearby sold prices

Free. Takes about twenty seconds.

Similar properties nearby