New
39
New
38
$534,900
258 James Street E, Orillia, ON L3V 1M2
Orillia
2 bd
2 ba
700 sf
4
2 days on marketMLS® S13774364
Listing courtesy of Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.
Orillia · L3V 3G5
$565,000
$514 / sq ft1 months on market
What similar homes in this area actually sold for.
What did similar homes nearby sell for?
Asking prices say what a seller wants. I'll send you what comparable homes in this area actually closed at, and how long they took.
Send me nearby sold pricesNo cost, no obligation.
CORNER LOT SIDESPLIT WITH BIG-TICKET UPDATES, A BACKYARD BUNKIE, FINISHED BASEMENT & OVERSIZED GARAGE! 423 Mary Street starts strong where buyers tend to look hardest, with a newer steel roof, updated windows, newer A/C, furnace (2025), water heater (2025), plus an oversized single garage and a 10x10 bunkie or shed for bikes, tools, hobby gear or the extras that never seem to fit inside. Set on a corner lot in a mature Orillia neighbourhood, this sidesplit has an updated front porch, ample driveway parking and a backyard with room for gardens, pets, play or future plans. The main level offers an open-concept living and dining area warmed by a gas fireplace, along with a practical kitchen featuring a newer dishwasher. The upper level keeps all three bedrooms together with a 4-piece bathroom, while the lower level adds a flexible fourth bedroom or office and a 3-piece bathroom. The finished basement extends the living space with a spacious rec room and convenient laundry featuring a new washer and dryer (2025). Additional highlights include central vac and an owned water heater, giving buyers one less rental item to factor in. Multiple parks, Harriett Todd P.S. and Twin Lakes S.S. are within walking distance, with the Orillia Rec Centre, Hwy 12, shopping, amenities and Orillia Soldiers' Memorial Hospital just a quick drive away. This #HomeToStay takes the sting out of homeownership by checking off the big-ticket essentials, leaving you free to focus on the fun stuff, like styling the open-concept main floor or deciding what that backyard bonus space could become.
Find out what this property has sold for before
If this address has traded before, I can tell you what it last sold for, when, and how the price moved along the way.
Show me this property's historyNo cost, no obligation.
What this home costs beyond the asking price, and how that price compares to what else is on the market.
This home is priced below most comparable listings — about 22% of comparable detached listings in Orillia are asking less.
Based on 95 comparable active detached listings in Orillia. These are asking prices, not sale prices.
Estimate only. Excludes CMHC insurance premiums, which apply below 20% down, and does not constitute a mortgage approval or an offer of credit.
Payable on closing, on top of the purchase price.
An estimate on the asking price of $565,000. Rates current as of September 2026; confirm the final figure with your real estate lawyer.
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX HALLMARK PEGGY HILL GROUP REALTY. Listing data is provided in part by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. Information is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties. Data is updated every 15 minutes.
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX REALTY ENTERPRISES INC.
$534,900
Orillia
Listing courtesy of Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.
$549,000
Orillia
Listing courtesy of Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.
$524,900
Orillia
Listing courtesy of FARIS TEAM REAL ESTATE BROKERAGE
$624,900
Orillia
Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
$658,900
Orillia
Listing courtesy of Cody Smith Real Estate Brokerage
