$2,188,800
3965 Algoma Avenue, Innisfil, ON L9S 2M1
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of ROYAL LEPAGE CITIZEN REALTY
Rural Innisfil · L9S 1X2
$1,999,900
$667 / sq ft1 weeks on market
Surrounded by lush greenery and mature trees, this exceptional custom-built residence in an exclusive Innisfil enclave offers a private country retreat experience on nearly 2.5 acres of park-like grounds, just minutes from Barrie and a short 10-minute walk to Lake Simcoe. Meticulously designed and maintained by its original owners, the nearly 5,000-square-foot family home showcases timeless workmanship, starting with a striking imported New York State white brick exterior and an expansive circular interlock driveway. Inside, spacious principal rooms feature custom millwork, hardwood, marble and porcelain tile, multiple fireplaces, and large windows that flood the home with natural light while framing tranquil views of the surrounding landscape. The upper level hosts four generously sized bedrooms, complemented by a main-floor office or nanny suite complete with a separate entrance and full bathroom. A bright walk-out lower level provides incredible flexibility for guest accommodations, additional bedrooms, or a private home office, while an upgraded natural gas radiant heating system ensures quiet, lasting efficiency throughout the seasons. Private yet connected, this rare legacy property combines refined luxury with everyday convenience, located moments from fine dining, golf, Friday Harbour Resort, major shopping, and the GO Station.
13 rooms. Dimensions as published by the listing brokerage.
| Room | Level | Dimensions | Features |
|---|---|---|---|
| Living Room | Main | 7.04 × 4.31 m23.1 × 14.1 ft | Hardwood Floor · Fireplace · Overlooks Backyard |
| Family Room | Main | 5.23 × 5.05 m17.2 × 16.6 ft | Hardwood Floor · Overlooks Backyard |
| Dining Room | Main | 4.34 × 3.45 m14.2 × 11.3 ft | Hardwood Floor |
| Kitchen | Main | 6.21 × 3.56 m20.4 × 11.7 ft | Eat-in Kitchen · Stainless Steel Appl · Quartz Counter |
| Bedroom | Main | 5.23 × 3.95 m17.2 × 13.0 ft | Hardwood Floor · 4 Pc Bath |
| Primary Bedroom | Second | 4.89 × 4.23 m16.0 × 13.9 ft | 4 Pc Ensuite · Walk-In Closet(s) · Large Window |
| Bedroom 2 | Second | 4.23 × 3.79 m13.9 × 12.4 ft | Hardwood Floor · Large Closet · Large Window |
| Bedroom 3 | Second | 4.37 × 3.41 m14.3 × 11.2 ft | Hardwood Floor · Large Closet · Large Window |
| Bedroom 4 | Second | 4.41 × 3.43 m14.5 × 11.3 ft | Hardwood Floor · Large Closet · Large Window |
| Game Room | Basement | 4.89 × 7.31 m16.0 × 24.0 ft | Walk-Out · Open Concept |
| Living Room | Basement | 3.34 × 5.16 m11.0 × 16.9 ft | Overlooks Backyard · Large Window |
| Library | Basement | 5.16 × 3.26 m16.9 × 10.7 ft | — |
| Exercise Room | Basement | 7.11 × 3.23 m23.3 × 10.6 ft | Open Concept |
This property's sale history is hidden
TRREB rules require a free account before sold and leased prices can be shown. One registration unlocks full sale history across the site.
Unlock sale history & sold priceFree. Takes about twenty seconds.
What this home costs beyond the asking price, and how that price compares to what else is on the market.
This home is priced above most comparable listings — about 94% of comparable detached listings in Rural Innisfil are asking less.
Based on 95 comparable active detached listings in Rural Innisfil. These are asking prices, not sale prices.
Estimate only. Excludes CMHC insurance premiums, which apply below 20% down, and does not constitute a mortgage approval or an offer of credit.
Payable on closing, on top of the purchase price.
An estimate on the asking price of $1,999,900. Rates current as of September 2026; confirm the final figure with your real estate lawyer.
Listing courtesy of FOREST HILL REAL ESTATE INC.. Listing data is provided in part by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. Information is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties. Data is updated every 15 minutes.
What similar homes in this area actually sold for.
Nearby sold prices are hidden
Recent closed sales for comparable homes in this area — the numbers that tell you whether the asking price is realistic.
Unlock nearby sold pricesFree. Takes about twenty seconds.
$2,188,800
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of ROYAL LEPAGE CITIZEN REALTY
$1,629,900
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of ENGEL & VOLKERS TORONTO CITY
$1,990,000
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 HERITAGE GROUP LTD.
$2,098,000
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX HALLMARK PEGGY HILL GROUP REALTY
$1,729,000
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of NEST SEEKERS INTERNATIONAL REAL ESTATE
$1,790,000
Rural Innisfil
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX HALLMARK CHAY REALTY