25
$899,900
58 Methodist Island, Tay, ON L0K 1R0
Port McNicoll
3 bd
2 ba
1,100 sf
1 months on marketMLS® S13588020
Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
31
Port McNicoll · L0K 1R0
$899,000
$300 / sq ft5 months on market
What similar homes in this area actually sold for.
What did similar homes nearby sell for?
Asking prices say what a seller wants. I'll send you what comparable homes in this area actually closed at, and how long they took.
Send me nearby sold pricesNo cost, no obligation.
$899,900
Port McNicoll
Listing courtesy of CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.
With its cupola, refined rooflines, and inviting front porch, this Cape Cod-inspired home makes a striking first impression. Tucked at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac in a gated waterfront community in Port McNicoll, the property is a short walk to the water's edge, offering over 3,000 sq ft of light-filled living space. Inside, the layout flows beautifully from the welcoming foyer to a bright, hexagon-shaped dining room overlooking the porch, an ideal space for hosting dinners or sipping your morning coffee. Vaulted ceilings & oversized windows create a sense of openness in the main living area, where a gas fireplace & a walkout to the screened-in porch set the tone for relaxed comfort. The main-floor primary suite includes a walk-in closet & 4-piece ensuite, while a nearby home office offers a quiet, inspiring place to work from home. The centrally located kitchen is designed for ease & connection, opening into the heart of the house. Upstairs, 2 bedrooms share a full bath. One connects to a balcony; the other enjoys its own private balcony - perfect for morning sun or quiet moments with a book. Built-in floor-to-ceiling shelving in the hallway offers an ideal space for a personal library or curated display. A loft overlooks the living room & opens to a shared balcony, blending style with function. At the top, a turret with transom windows offers fantastic views & a peaceful space for reading or stargazing. The basement provides ample storage, & the large double garage adds practical convenience. Outdoors, enjoy evenings around the stone fire pit or listen to birdsong from the comfort of the screened-in porch. A public walking trail runs along the northern edge of the property, & multiple marinas are just minutes away - perfectly situated for boaters seeking quick access to launch points on Georgian Bay. Just a short drive to Midland for shopping, dining & essential amenities, this home offers a refined four-season lifestyle. Seller is open to VTB financing
Find out what this property has sold for before
If this address has traded before, I can tell you what it last sold for, when, and how the price moved along the way.
Show me this property's historyNo cost, no obligation.
What this home costs beyond the asking price, and how that price compares to what else is on the market.
This home is priced in line with comparable listings — about 67% of comparable detached listings in Port McNicoll are asking less.
Based on 27 comparable active detached listings in Port McNicoll. These are asking prices, not sale prices.
Estimate only. Excludes CMHC insurance premiums, which apply below 20% down, and does not constitute a mortgage approval or an offer of credit.
Payable on closing, on top of the purchase price.
An estimate on the asking price of $899,000. Rates current as of September 2026; confirm the final figure with your real estate lawyer.
Listing courtesy of Sotheby's International Realty Canada. Listing data is provided in part by the Toronto Regional Real Estate Board (TRREB) and is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate. Information is for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties. Data is updated every 15 minutes.
$769,000
Port McNicoll
Listing courtesy of Royal LePage In Touch Realty
$999,000
Port McNicoll
Listing courtesy of HOMELIFE/VISION REALTY INC.
$734,777
Port McNicoll
Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd
